Craig Agency Logo
Get a Quote!
call today 315-303-7020


We as a church, and also myself personally, have Cindy Craig as our insurance agent for many years. Our church was insured by her agency in 1995. She is always helpful in every situation. Insurance is something I know nothing about. It is comforting to be able to have someone who is knowledgeable and personal when it comes to types and suggestions of insurance. I would recommend Cindy Craig and her agency for any church and pastor. There has always been a very professional and courteous response from the Craig Agency.
Pastor Terry Fenton, Seneca Bible Baptist Church, Seneca Falls, NY
Beth is a wonderful agent when it comes to insurance. She is professional, considerate, friendly, and attentive to her clients. Whenever we have questions, she would get back to us in a timely manner. We feel comfortable speaking with her too; always smiling and in a delightful mood. In addition to her positive personality, she help us save money on insurance. She always try to find the best fit for our budget. We have several policies ensured through her agency. We highly recommend Beth to anyone looking for insurance.
Ethan and Scott, Owners of Vapor Dragon in Baldwinsville, NY
Cindy at Craig Agency is an exceptional agent. She is knowledgeable and professional and always provides excellent service. Her perspective as a pastor's wife is invaluable, as she knows so much about how a church and it's ministries operate. I would highly recommend her to every pastor and church out there!
Pastor George Burkinshaw, Calvary Bible Baptist Church, Elbridge, NY
It is with much confidence that I recommend Beth Burton for any of your insurance needs. She insures my business as well as my personal needs. She is very accessible and always aggressive in getting me the best prices for my business as well as for myself and my family. Please consider giving her a chance for your insurance needs.
Jonah Dombroski, Timber Taverns
Dear Cindy, You are such a blessing to me. You have saved me money and helped me keep my sanity!
Joyce Betancourt
I can personally attest to the fact that the team at Craig Agency does their best in going the extra mile to provide a personal touch to find the products that will suit each person's individual needs at the lowest cost! Thank You Craig Agency!
Anna Vogel
The Craig Agency has been great to deal with. They rapidly respond to questions we've had for the church as well as our personal insurance. It is very convenient they have a church quote sheet you can fill in right on their website.
Pastor Stan Jordan, Assistant Pastor, Cornerstone Fellowship, Newark, NY
An acquaintance referred me to Craig Agency, so I called to get a quote. I was just looking to save a few bucks but what I was given was so much more than that!! Beth Burton put her time and care into getting to know every important detail about our family, in order get us the best insurance plan for our situation. She was so kind, patient and knowledgeable. Beth would explain all the ins and outs, which helped me to really understand things that every homeowner should know! Not only that, but when she told me she could save us THOUSANDS of dollars my jaw hit the floor!! In result, I am very proud to say that Craig Agency is now my agency and Beth Burton is now my "go to" girl!
Bethleann Trovato
I would heartily recommend Cindy Craig to churches that are looking to save money on their on their insurance but not have to sacrifice quality and service. Our church was broken into last fall and the attention that was given to our claim was fast, courteous and equitable. Craig Agency represents good companies and take care of their clients.
Pastor David Dunbar, Freedom Baptist Church, Auburn, NY
We've been with the Craig Agency for several years and are most definitely pleased with the service we've been receiving. Cindy tailored a policy for us that met our needs and yet was affordable. They are always quick to respond to any inquiry and Cindy is very knowledgeable regarding the needs of churches, being the wife of a pastor. I highly recommend the Craig Agency and know you will be pleased as much as I am when you make that call to take advantage of the tremendous expertise.
Pastor Nick Cultrara, First Baptist Church of Frewsburg, NY
Beth saved us money when we switched to her and before our policy renewed she shopped around for us again without us even having to ask, saving us even more money! She has been very helpful in getting the answers we need. She always makes herself available whenever we need assistance and I couldn't be happier with her service!
Kevin and Hollie Rickner, Rochester NY

Quick Quote Form

First Last

Craig Agency
43 Oswego Street, ste 200
Baldwinsville, NY 13027
Phone: 315-303-7020
Get Map
Email Us

Facebook LinkedIn Blog RSS Feed